Reputation management for surgical practices

Great outcomes deserve great reviews.
Most never get written.

Your patients walk again, see clearly, and feel like themselves. Most of them never post about it, simply because nobody asked at the right moment. We ask after recovery, reply to every review in a HIPAA-conscious way, and keep every surgeon’s profile accurate everywhere patients look.

★★★★★ 4.9 / 5 · 250+ reviews
HIPAA-conscious
No long-term contracts
FREE · 60 SECONDS

See If You Qualify

We only work with surgical practices ready to grow.

Can you take on more clients this month?

What's your company's current annual revenue?

How much are you currently investing in marketing per month?

Book Your 20-Minute Intro Call

Schedule a quick call to review where your businesss is today and see if we'd be a good fit to help you

Trusted by surgical practices across the United States

Summit Orthopedic & Spine
Lakeview Surgical Associates
Northshore Bariatric Center
Crestline Plastic Surgery
Clearview Eye Surgeons
Riverbend ENT & Sinus
Summit Orthopedic & Spine
Lakeview Surgical Associates
Northshore Bariatric Center
Crestline Plastic Surgery
Clearview Eye Surgeons
Riverbend ENT & Sinus

Why great practices have weak ratings

Happy patients move on. Hard recoveries get posted.

Most surgical patients are grateful for their results. Without a careful system, your rating reflects the rare difficult recovery instead of the many great outcomes.

Your happiest patients go quiet.

Once a patient is walking without pain or loving their results, life moves on. Nobody asks for a review, so years of great outcomes never show up online.

A hard recovery becomes a harsh review.

Complications, slow recoveries, and billing surprises happen in surgery. Without more recent reviews around it, one painful review becomes the first thing new patients read.

A careless reply can break HIPAA.

A well-meant reply like "We're sorry your knee replacement recovery was difficult" confirms the reviewer is a patient and shares their procedure. Healthcare providers have been fined for exactly this.

Your reviews are scattered.

Patients review your practice, individual surgeons, and directory pages like Healthgrades, Vitals, and RealSelf. Without a plan, no single profile builds the strength it should.

The first question everyone asks

Which reviews can actually be removed?

Most practices hear “it depends” followed by a proposal. Here are the honest odds, so you know what’s realistic before you spend anything.

Often removable

Breaks the rules

Reviews that break platform policy can be reported, and platforms do act.

  • Fake or competitor reviewsSomeone who was never a patient, or a rival practice posing as one.
  • Former staff posing as patientsReviews about a former employer are a conflict of interest under Google's rules.
  • Someone else's private detailsReviews that expose another person's name, contact details, or health information.
  • Harassment or profanityAbusive, hateful, or completely off-topic content.
Sometimes

Depends on proof

Worth trying, but the odds depend on evidence and the platform.

  • Reviews meant for another practiceA patient who confused you with another practice or a hospital system. Often fixable with a polite request.
  • Provably false statementsA stated fact that isn't true, not an opinion. Where platforms won't act, it becomes a matter for a lawyer, not a marketer.
Stays

Real and accurate

Platforms protect these on purpose. Be wary of anyone who says otherwise.

  • Genuine reviews from real patientsEven unfair ones, including reviews written after a difficult recovery.
  • A patient's own storyPatients can share their own surgery experience. Your reply just can't confirm any of it.
For anything that stays, the fix is what surrounds it. More recent reviews from happy patients, professional replies, and strong profiles make one bad review a small part of a much better picture.

What we do

More reviews. Better replies. No shortcuts.

The best way to improve a rating isn’t deleting reviews. It’s asking every patient at the right point in their recovery, and replying to every review the right way.

Post-Recovery Review Requests

Review requests sent after recovery milestones, when patients are seeing their results, never in the first painful days after surgery.

  • Timed to recovery milestones
  • Connected to your practice systems
  • Pointed at the right profile

HIPAA-Conscious Replies

Every review answered professionally. Replies never confirm someone is a patient or mention any procedure details.

  • Replies to positive and negative reviews
  • Sensitive replies sent to you for approval
  • Privacy-safe templates for your team

Removal Requests

Fake reviews, competitor reviews, and reviews exposing someone else's private details, reported and tracked until resolved.

  • Policy violation reports
  • Honest odds before we start
  • No charges for hopeless attempts

Private Feedback Alerts

A short feedback check alongside every request, so concerns reach your practice administrator privately and can be handled with care.

  • Instant alerts to your team
  • Concerns sent to the right person
  • Follow-up tracking

Surgeon & Directory Profiles

Your practice and every surgeon kept accurate across Google and the medical directories patients check.

  • Individual surgeon profiles
  • Healthgrades, Vitals, and RealSelf
  • Duplicate listing cleanup

Monitoring & Reports

New reviews and rating changes across every platform, with alerts going to you as well as us.

  • Real-time review alerts
  • Monthly rating and volume reports
  • Hospital and competitor comparison

Worth asking any agency

Do they ask every patient, or just the happy ones?

A lot of review software surveys patients first and only sends the happy ones to Google. It raises the average, and it breaks the rules.

What we won't do

Review gating

  • Who gets asked

    A survey first, and only happy patients are sent to Google

  • Unhappy patients

    Quietly routed to a private inbox nobody checks

  • The rules

    Against Google's and Yelp's review policies, and FTC guidance

  • The risk

    Penalties land on your profile, not the software vendor's

  • How it looks

    A suspiciously perfect rating patients don't fully trust

What we do instead

Ask every patient

  • Who gets asked

    Every patient receives the same review request

  • Unhappy patients

    A separate feedback check flags problems to your team right away

  • The rules

    Fully within every platform's policies

  • The risk

    None to your profile, and problems get fixed early

  • How it looks

    A real, steady rating with thoughtful replies patients can trust

Specialties we serve

Reviews that speak to every surgical specialty.

Patients read reviews from people who had the same procedure. Reviews that mention specific surgeries help the right patients choose you.

Orthopedic & Spine

Reviews about getting back to walking, playing, and working help patients in pain trust your surgeons.

Bariatric & General

Reviews that mention support before and after surgery reassure patients facing a major life change.

Plastic & Reconstructive

Cosmetic patients read reviews closely, including on RealSelf. Steady, recent reviews show the quality of your results.

Eye, ENT & Specialty

Reviews that mention clear vision, easier breathing, and a smooth experience help patients choose you for specialty care.

Our commitments

Promises worth holding us to.

Reputation work runs on trust. These are the rules we follow on every account.

100%

Asked the same way

Every patient receives the same review request

0

Fake reviews

No fake, bought, or incentivized reviews, ever

1 day

Typical reply time

On new reviews, with sensitive replies approved by you

100%

Yours to keep

Your profiles stay in your name

How it works

Requests first. Removals last.

Reversing this order is the most common and expensive mistake in reputation management.

01.

Free reputation audit

We review every platform where patients can find you, including surgeon profiles and medical directories, and show your rating, review count, and unanswered reviews next to nearby practices and hospitals.

02.

Set up post-recovery requests

We agree on the right recovery milestones for each procedure, then connect review requests to your practice systems.

03.

Clear the backlog

Every unanswered review gets a professional, HIPAA-conscious reply, oldest first, with sensitive ones sent to you for approval.

04.

Report what breaks the rules

Fake reviews, competitor reviews, and privacy violations, reported and tracked, with honest odds before we start.

05.

Monitor & report

Ongoing alerts, replies, and monthly reports, so you always know where your rating is heading and why.

FAQS

Reputation questions, answered honestly.

What practice owners ask us about reviews, replies, and removals.

Can you get a bad review removed?

Sometimes. If a review breaks platform rules, such as a fake review, a competitor, a former employee posing as a patient, or content exposing someone else's private details, we report it and platforms often act. A genuine review from a real patient stays, even if it was written after a difficult recovery.

When is the best time to ask surgical patients for a review?

After recovery milestones, when patients are seeing their results, like walking comfortably after a joint replacement or loving how they look after a cosmetic procedure. Requests are never sent in the first painful days after surgery.

How should we respond to a review about a complication?

Professionally, and without any details. A good reply acknowledges their concern, never confirms they were a patient or mentions their procedure, and invites them to contact the practice directly. We write these replies for you and send them for your approval first.

Do you only ask happy patients for reviews?

No. Every patient receives the same request. Asking only happy patients, often called review gating, is against Google's rules. Separately, a private feedback check lets concerns reach your team so they can be addressed quickly.

What about Healthgrades, Vitals, and RealSelf?

Many patients check these directories before choosing a surgeon, and RealSelf is especially important for cosmetic procedures. We monitor them, keep surgeon profiles accurate, and respond where the platform allows.

How long until our rating improves?

It depends on how many reviews you have now and how many patients you see. With requests going out after every recovery milestone, most practices see real progress within a few months.

Client voices

What surgeons actually say.

Pulled from verified Google reviews and client interviews. Full versions on our reviews page.

“

★★★★★

Their digital strategy significantly improved our search rankings in Google and ChatGPT, and we've seen a noticeable increase in calls and consult requests from local patients. The results have been clear and consistent.

DD
David D. Lakeview Surgical Associates
“

★★★★★

Their digital marketing strategy helped us reach local patients specifically looking for joint replacement and spine surgery. The result has been a steady increase in qualified consults and scheduled cases within our area.

JM
John M. Summit Orthopedic & Spine

See what patients see when they look you up.

Send us your practice’s name. We’ll check every review platform, including surgeon profiles and medical directories, along with your replies and nearby practices’ ratings, then tell you what’s realistic to improve. If you don’t need us, we’ll tell you that too.

PREFER TO TALK?

Call us - a real person will pick up.

HoursMon-Fri · 7am-9pm ET
Sat · 8am-4pm ET

CarePilot Logo

The digital marketing partner built exclusively for surgical practices. We help surgeons build sustainable patient pipelines, one case at a time.

CONTACT

(866) 916-1145

[email protected]

Serving surgical practices across all 50 states · USA & Canada based